
Displaying items by tag: terrorism
Holcim pays the price
19 October 2022Doing deals with terrorists has a price: US$778m. The US Department of Justice (DOJ) revealed this week that it had fined Lafarge for its conduct in Syria between 2013 and 2014. In addition Lafarge and its subsidiary Lafarge Cement Syria (LCS) have pleaded guilty to one count of conspiring to provide material support to designated foreign terrorist organisations in Syria. It is uncertain how exactly the fine will be paid but it is worth noting that successor company Holcim reported net sales of nearly US$27bn in 2021. The fine represents nearly 2% of this.
A reasonable amount of new detail can be found on the DOJ website. LCS was essentially dealing with the Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham (ISIS) and the al-Nusrah Front (ANF) as they would a local government in relation to the running of the Jalabiyeh cement plant. As a reminder, both of these groups were defined as terrorist organisations by the US government at the time. The relationship apparently started as monthly payments to local armed groups, including ISIS and ANF, to allow movement through checkpoints. This later progressed to a de-facto tax based on cement sales. However, it became worse when LCS started asking ISIS to block or tax imports of cement from Turkey-based competitors into northern Syria as part of a revenue-sharing agreement. Effectively LCS was fixing the price of cement in a war zone by collaborating with terrorists. In the end LCS, the intermediaries and the terrorist groups made around US$80m whilst they were working together.
Holcim’s interpretation of the ruling was keen to point out that the conduct in Syria was recognised by the DOJ as not involving Holcim in any way. The DOJ did agree that Lafarge’s executives didn't disclose their activities in Syria to its successor company Holcim either before or after the merger in 2015. However, it pointed out that Holcim had not carried out due diligence of LCS’s operations in Syria. It added that, “Lafarge, LCS and the successor company also did not self-report the conduct or fully cooperate in the investigation.”
Despite this, other information that Holcim also highlighted was that the US authorities were now happy that effective compliance and risk management controls were in place to prevent anything similar happening again. Crucially, it said that the DOJ didn’t think that an independent compliance monitor was required. It pointed out that none of the conduct involved Lafarge’s operations or employees in the US and that none of the Lafarge executives were working for Holcim or any associated company. Finally, the group wanted to report that the DOJ found that none of the former Lafarge executives involved shared any of the “methods, goals or ideologies” of the terrorist groups operating in area at the time.
The immediate reaction from all of this is what happens to the ongoing legal case in France, also about Lafarge’s conduct in Syria? In mid-May 2022 the Court of Appeals confirmed a charge of complicity in crimes against humanity against Lafarge. The company then reportedly started the appeal process at the Supreme Court. Other charges, including financing terrorism, endangering life and violating an embargo, were lodged earlier in the legal process. The US is generally seen as being the leading prosecutor of international corporate crime but if the French legal system also issued a fine to Lafarge on the same scale things could become difficult for Holcim. The other complication for the French legal case is that the national intelligence services allegedly used Lafarge’s links with the Syrian terror groups to acquire information but they did not warn the company that it was committing a crime.
Holcim is a different company from what it was when LafargeHolcim formed in 2015. It is being run by a new chief executive officer who came in from another company well after the merger and is diversifying away from the trio of cement, concrete and aggregates with the addition of a fourth business area of light building materials. Alongside this the group has been selling off businesses in the developing world and focusing on Europe and North America. Yet it is still being defined by the criminal actions of a company it absorbed seven years ago and the behaviour of staff long gone. Those actions have been investigated and punishment delivered. More may be coming.
Lafarge Cement Syria fined US$778m for terror support
19 October 2022Syria/US: A US court has found Lafarge Cement Syria guilty of conspiring to provide material support to the terrorist organisations al-Nusrah Front (ANF) and ISIS in Northern Syria during 2013 and 2014. Lafarge Cement Syria and its parent company, France-based Lafarge, agreed in 2011 to pay the terrorists for Lafarge Cement Syria employees' 'protection' and the continuation of the Jalabiyeh cement plant's operations, as well as to gain an economic advantage over other Syrian competitors. During the duration of the agreement, Lafarge Cement Syria recorded US$70.3m in sales. Coalition forces fighting against ANF and ISIS damaged the plant in an airstrike 'to reduce the facility's military usefulness' on 16 October 2019.
The court ordered Lafarge Cement Syria to pay criminal fines and forfeiture totaling US$778m.
France: The Court of Appeals has confirmed a charge of complicity in crimes against humanity against Lafarge, now part of Holcim. The company will now appeal the decision to the Supreme Court. The confirmation establishes the scope of the charges that Lafarge will face, if unsuccessful in its appeal.
Global Cement previously reported that Lafarge allegedly made indirect payments to terror organisation ISIS between 2011 and 2014 in order to keep its Jalabiya cement plant operational during the Syrian Civil War. French prosecutors opened an investigation into the company’s activities in the country in June 2017, leading to its indictment for complicity in crimes against humanity on 28 June 2018.
France: The Court of Cassation has denied Lafarge’s appeals against the charge of complicity in crimes against humanity in Syria. The court of last resort has reversed the decision by the Paris Court of Appeal in 2019, according to the Agence France Presse. The case has now been referred back to investigating magistrates for reconsideration along with another charge of ‘endangering the lives of others.’ In a statement Lafarge said that the decision by the Court of Cassation did not in any way presume any guilt on its part and that it would continue to cooperate fully.
The legal case relates to the conduct of Lafarge in Syria between 2011 and 2014. Lafarge and Holcim later merged in 2015 becoming LafargeHolcim. LafargeHolcim’s shareholders voted to change the company’s name to Holcim in May 2021.
Iraq: Joint security forces have repelled militants from the Kubiasa cement plant in Al-Anbar province. Iraqi News has reported that 18 fighters from the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) were killed in the operation. The security forces also detonated four car bombs at the site.
France/Syria: The Court of Cassation, a court of last resort, has delayed its ruling on the conduct of Lafarge in Syria between 2011 and 2014 until September 2021. It was due to make a decision on a number of appeals related to the case including whether charges of charge of crimes against humanity should be upheld, according to the Agence France Presse. Other indictments include those of financing terrorism, endangering life and violating an embargo. Lafarge has been accused of financing terrorism through indirect payments to extremist groups to keep its Jalabiya cement plant operational after the outbreak of war in Syria.
Lafarge Cement Syria was a subsidiary of Lafarge in the early 2010s. Lafarge and Holcim merged in 2015 becoming LafargeHolcim. LafargeHolcim’s shareholders later voted to change the company’s name to Holcim in May 2021.
Bombs found at India Cements plant in Tamil Nadu
23 June 2021India: Two pipe bombs have been found by police at India Cements plant at Sankarnagar, Tirunelveli in Tamil Nadu. The explosives were discovered after the plant manager was asked for a ransom of around US$70,000, according to the Indo-Asian News Service. Police suspect that the bombs were left at the site by former employees whose contracts were terminated due to coronavirus-related restrictions. However, terrorist activity is also being considered. The cement producer said that no one was hurt in the incident and production at the site continues uninterrupted.
France/Syria: The Court of Cassation, a court of last resort, is considering whether a charge of crimes against humanity should be upheld against Lafarge. However, charges of financing terrorism, endangering life and violating an embargo seem set to stay. The legal case is investigating the company’s conduct in Syria between 2011 and 2014. It has been accused of financing terrorism through indirect payments to extremist groups to keep its Jalabiya cement plant operational after the outbreak of war in Syria. The Court of Cassation is expected to deliver its verdict on 15 July 2021.
Bomb attack causes injury at Star Cement’s Meghalaya cement plant
14 December 2020India: The Hynniewtrep National Liberation Council (HNLC) has claimed responsibility for an improvised explosive device (IED) blast which injured one person and damaged a wall and water pipes at Star Cement’s cement plant in the East Jaintia Hills district of Meghalaya. The Press Trust of India has reported that the attack resulted from the producer’s failure to pay protection money as a non-locally-owned business.
Saurya Cement quarry blasts injure five
04 December 2020Nepal: Four explosions at Saurya Cement’s Udayapur quarry in Province No. 1 have injured five workers. The Republica newspaper has reported that the cause was allegedly a bombing campaign by an unidentified group, which also destroyed two vehicles. Police described the conditions of the victims, who are receiving treatment in Katari Hospital, as ’normal.’ The incident follows a similar event at the Tapli rural municipality office in the district in November 2020.